203.DSC 101-My Last Duchess (7)

1. Critical Appreciation

"My Last Duchess" is a dramatic monologue written by Robert Browning, first published in 1842. The poem is narrated by a Renaissance Duke who is showcasing a portrait of his late wife to a visitor, possibly a marriage broker negotiating the Duke's next marriage. The poem explores themes of power, control, jealousy, and the objectification of women.

One striking feature of the poem is its form—a dramatic monologue—which allows Browning to delve into the mind of the Duke and present his perspective directly to the reader. This narrative choice not only provides insight into the Duke's character but also invites readers to question the reliability of the speaker. The Duke's tone is one of casual arrogance, and his language is refined, reflecting his status and self-importance.

The opening lines set the tone, as the Duke proudly displays the portrait of his deceased wife, referring to it as "My Last Duchess." The possessive pronoun "my" immediately establishes the possessive and controlling nature of the Duke. The painting becomes a symbol of the Duke's authority over his wife, as he alone possesses and controls the image. The reader is left to wonder why the Duchess is the Duke's "last" and what happened to her.

As the Duke describes the portrait, he reveals subtle details about the Duchess's personality and behavior. He mentions her "spot of joy" and her ability to appreciate simple pleasures, such as the sunset. However, he finds fault with her for being easily pleased, suggesting that her affable nature was a threat to his desire for complete dominance. The Duke's jealousy and desire for control are evident as he recalls her reactions to gifts and gestures from others.

The Duke's recounting of the story of the portrait hints at the darker events that led to the Duchess's demise. He mentions that the Duchess treated everyone equally, whether it was the "officious fool" or the "painter." The mention of the artist as an "officious fool" hints at the Duke's dissatisfaction with the attention the Duchess gave to others. The Duke's extreme possessiveness becomes apparent when he reveals that he "gave commands" that resulted in the smiling portrait being replaced by a curtain. The act of covering the portrait suggests the Duke's desire to conceal his wife's genuine happiness and keep her image under his control.

Browning skillfully uses the Duke's language and perspective to create a chilling effect. The reader becomes an unwitting listener, drawn into the Duke's unsettling mindset. The poem raises questions about the nature of art, power dynamics in relationships, and the consequences of unchecked jealousy. The Duke's control over the narrative and the portrait becomes a metaphor for his broader desire for dominance in all aspects of his life.

In conclusion, "My Last Duchess" is a powerful exploration of human psychology, jealousy, and the abuse of power. Through the Duke's narrative, Browning creates a character who is both fascinating and repulsive, prompting readers to reflect on the darker aspects of human nature. The poem's enduring appeal lies in its ability to provoke thought and discussion about the complexities of relationships and the consequences of unchecked ego and possessiveness.

2. As a dramatic monologue

"My Last Duchess" by Robert Browning is a classic example of a dramatic monologue, a poetic form that allows a single character to speak directly to the audience or a silent listener. In this case, the Duke serves as both narrator and character, revealing his thoughts and emotions as he describes a portrait of his late wife to an envoy. The poem, composed in iambic pentameter, unfolds in a single, uninterrupted speech, providing readers with a glimpse into the psyche of the Duke.

The dramatic monologue form enables Browning to craft a narrative that is not only a character study but also a subtle exploration of complex themes such as power, control, jealousy, and art. The monologue begins abruptly, with the Duke introducing the envoy to his late wife's portrait, immediately setting the stage for the unfolding drama. The controlled and articulate language used by the Duke suggests his aristocratic upbringing and positions him as a character accustomed to wielding power.

The structure of the monologue is crucial in conveying the Duke's mindset. The lack of interruption allows for an uninterrupted flow of the Duke's thoughts, creating an intimate connection between the character and the reader. The poem consists of 56 rhymed couplets, contributing to its formal and controlled tone. The rhyme scheme, AABB, adds a sense of order to the Duke's narrative, contrasting with the disturbing content of his speech.

The central theme of "My Last Duchess" revolves around the Duke's possessive and controlling nature. The title itself, with its possessive pronoun, establishes the Duke's proprietary attitude toward his late wife. The use of "last" hints at the Duke's history of failed marriages and serves as a foreboding element, inviting readers to question the circumstances surrounding the previous duchess's departure.

As the Duke describes the portrait, he reveals subtle details about the Duchess's personality, emphasizing her innocence and warmth. However, the Duke's jealousy and need for control emerge as he recalls her interactions with others. The Duchess's ability to find joy in simple things, such as the sunset or a gift from a commoner, threatens the Duke's desire for exclusive dominion over her emotions.

One of the critical elements of a dramatic monologue is the reliability of the narrator. In "My Last Duchess," Browning masterfully employs the unreliable narrator trope, as the Duke's perspective is the sole lens through which the events are filtered. The reader is left to question the accuracy of the Duke's account, especially considering his vested interest in presenting himself as the victim of his wife's alleged indiscretions.

The Duke's jealousy is further emphasized when he recounts the story of the portrait and the painter. He takes offense at the Duchess's willingness to express gratitude to the artist, referring to him as an "officious fool." This choice of words reveals the Duke's disdain for anyone who might share a connection with the Duchess, even a mere painter. The Duke's manipulation extends to his control over the portrait, as he admits to giving commands that resulted in the covering of the painting. The veil becomes a symbolic representation of the Duke's power to conceal his wife's genuine emotions and, metaphorically, to shroud the truth.

The Duke's language is both refined and ominous, creating a chilling effect. His nonchalant admission of having "commands" and taking offense at the Duchess's egalitarian nature suggests a deep-seated sense of entitlement. The Duke's perception of the Duchess as an object to be controlled is evident in his disregard for her agency and autonomy.

Browning's use of dramatic irony is noteworthy in this monologue. The Duke remains oblivious to the fact that his very narrative exposes his flaws and moral shortcomings. The reader, however, gains insight into the Duke's character through his words, allowing for a richer understanding of the psychological dynamics at play.

The poem's lasting impact lies in its ability to provoke introspection and discussion about human relationships, power dynamics, and the consequences of unchecked possessiveness. The dramatic monologue form serves as a powerful vehicle for Browning to delve into the complexities of the Duke's character, making "My Last Duchess" a timeless exploration of the darker facets of human nature. The controlled structure and eloquent language heighten the poem's impact, leaving readers with a haunting portrayal of a man consumed by his desire for control and dominance.

3. Themes

"My Last Duchess" by Robert Browning is a poem rich with thematic depth, exploring various aspects of human nature, power dynamics, art, and the consequences of unchecked jealousy. In this exploration, we'll delve into the prominent themes that contribute to the enduring significance of the poem.

1. Power and Control:

   At the core of "My Last Duchess" is the theme of power and control. The Duke, as the narrator, reveals a possessive and domineering nature. His insistence on referring to the Duchess as "My Last Duchess" immediately establishes a possessive relationship. The Duke's ability to dictate the fate of the portrait and control the narrative surrounding the Duchess's life reflects his overarching desire for power and dominance. The poem serves as a commentary on the misuse of authority in relationships, portraying the detrimental effects of one individual's unchecked control over another.

2. Jealousy and Possessiveness:

   Jealousy is a pervasive theme in the poem, driving much of the Duke's narrative. The Duchess's capacity for joy and appreciation, whether for art or nature, becomes a source of jealousy for the Duke. He resents her ability to find delight in simple things, especially when those sources of joy come from interactions with others. The Duke's possessiveness extends beyond the realm of his deceased wife to encompass the portrait itself. His jealousy becomes a destructive force, leading to his decision to conceal the genuine smile captured in the painting and replace it with a curtain.

3. Art and Representation:

   The poem also explores the theme of art and its role in representing reality. The portrait of the Duchess becomes a symbol of both her life and the Duke's control. The artist, whose skill is acknowledged by the Duke as the "officious fool," inadvertently captures the genuine emotion of the Duchess in the painting. However, the Duke's manipulation of the portrait reveals the subjective nature of art as a tool for representation. The veil becomes a metaphorical shroud, illustrating the Duke's power to distort the truth and present a curated version of his late wife.

4. Social Class and Aristocracy:

   The Duke's aristocratic status and sense of entitlement are evident throughout the poem. His disdain for the lower social classes, exemplified in his derogatory reference to the painter as an "officious fool," highlights the class-based hierarchies of the time. The Duke's belief in his inherent superiority contributes to his expectation of unquestioning obedience and loyalty from those around him. The poem serves as a critique of the aristocratic mindset and the societal norms that allowed such individuals to wield immense power over others.

5. Ego and Narcissism:

   The Duke's narrative is marked by an underlying sense of ego and narcissism. He presents himself as a collector of art and women, showcasing both as possessions that reflect his status and importance. The Duke's recounting of the Duchess's interactions with others reveals his inability to tolerate any attention or admiration directed away from himself. His ego-driven decisions, such as covering the portrait, speak to a narcissistic desire to control not only how others perceive him but also how they perceive his late wife.

6. Gender Roles and Objectification:

   The poem touches on gender roles and the objectification of women in the context of the Duke's relationships. The Duchess is reduced to an object, both in the title ("My Last Duchess") and through the controlled narrative presented by the Duke. Her agency is stripped away, and she becomes a mere reflection of the Duke's desires and expectations. The poem raises questions about the societal norms that allowed women to be treated as possessions and the consequences of such objectification on individual lives.

7. Irony and Unreliable Narrator:

   "My Last Duchess" employs dramatic irony, wherein the audience is aware of something that the character is not. The Duke, in his attempt to present himself as a victim of the Duchess's perceived transgressions, unwittingly reveals his own moral shortcomings. The gap between the Duke's perception of events and the reader's understanding adds layers of complexity to the narrative, inviting critical reflection on the reliability of the narrator and the true nature of the Duchess's fate.

In conclusion, "My Last Duchess" encapsulates a myriad of themes that continue to resonate with readers. Browning's exploration of power dynamics, jealousy, art, and societal norms provides a multi-faceted lens through which to examine the complexities of human relationships. The poem's enduring relevance lies in its ability to prompt critical reflection on the darker aspects of human nature and the consequences of unbridled power and possession. Through the Duke's narrative, Browning invites readers to confront uncomfortable truths about the potential for abuse within relationships and the societal structures that enable such behavior.

4. Impact of Age

The theme of age in "My Last Duchess" by Robert Browning adds a nuanced layer to the exploration of power dynamics, control, and societal expectations. While the poem primarily revolves around the Duke's possessive nature and his relationship with his late wife, considerations of age and its impact on the characters and their interactions contribute to the overall complexity of the narrative.

1. Age as a Symbol of Authority:

   The Duke's age is implied through his position as a nobleman and the head of the household. In the context of the poem, age becomes a symbol of authority and entitlement. The Duke's sense of superiority and his expectation of unquestioning obedience are heightened by his advanced years. The societal norms of the time granted significant power to individuals based on their age and social standing, and the Duke embodies this authority in his interactions with others.

2. Generational Divide and Social Expectations:

   The Duke's advanced age creates a generational divide between him and the younger characters in the poem, including his late wife. This divide is marked not only by age but also by differences in societal expectations and values. The Duke's adherence to rigid social norms and his belief in the unquestionable authority of the aristocracy reflect the conservative attitudes associated with his generation. The contrast between the Duke's worldview and the more liberal attitudes of the younger characters contributes to the tension within the poem.

3. Impact of Age on Relationships:

   The age difference between the Duke and the Duchess becomes a significant factor in their relationship dynamics. The Duke's need for control and possessiveness may, in part, stem from a perceived threat to his authority due to the Duchess's youthfulness. Her ability to find joy in simple things and interact freely with others may be viewed by the Duke as a challenge to his status as the dominant figure in their relationship. The age gap accentuates the power dynamic between the characters and fuels the Duke's jealousy.

4. Erosion of Youth and Beauty:

   The Duchess's youth and beauty are central to the poem's narrative, and the Duke's recounting of her interactions with others emphasizes the ephemeral nature of these qualities. The mention of the "spot of joy" on her cheek and her genuine smiles captures a moment in time when her youth and beauty were at their peak. However, the Duke's decision to have the portrait covered with a curtain suggests a desire to preserve and control that moment, preventing the natural aging process from diminishing the image of his late wife.

5. Age and the Perception of Women:

   The societal expectations of the time placed considerable emphasis on the youth and beauty of women. The Duke's objectification of the Duchess is intertwined with societal norms that valued women for their physical attributes and their ability to conform to societal expectations. The age-related dynamics in the poem reflect broader attitudes toward women in a patriarchal society, where their worth is often tied to their appearance and compliance with societal norms.

6. Reflection on Mortality:

   The Duke's age also prompts reflection on mortality and the passing of time. As an older character, the Duke is confronted with the inevitability of death and the transient nature of life. The portrait becomes a means for him to immortalize a moment in time, attempting to defy the aging process and preserve the image of his wife in a state of perpetual beauty. The Duke's manipulation of the portrait is, in part, a response to his own awareness of the fleeting nature of life and the inevitability of death.

7. Impact on the Unreliable Narrator:

   The Duke's age influences his perspective and contributes to his status as an unreliable narrator. His worldview is shaped by the societal norms of his time, including the expectations associated with age and social standing. The Duke's inability to understand or appreciate the Duchess's more youthful and liberal outlook is rooted in his adherence to the values of his generation. The age-related bias of the Duke contributes to the dramatic irony in the poem, as readers can discern the limitations of his perspective.

In conclusion, the theme of age in "My Last Duchess" plays a significant role in shaping the characters, their relationships, and the societal context in which they exist. The Duke's advanced age contributes to his sense of entitlement, authority, and possessiveness. The generational gap between the characters underscores the societal expectations and values of the time, adding layers of complexity to the exploration of power dynamics and control. Additionally, age serves as a lens through which the poem reflects on mortality, societal norms, and the impact of time on relationships. Through the nuanced consideration of age, Browning enriches the thematic depth of "My Last Duchess," inviting readers to contemplate the interplay of age, power, and societal expectations in the unfolding narrative.

5. Robert Browning

Robert Browning, a Victorian poet and playwright, is celebrated for his innovative use of dramatic monologue and profound exploration of human psychology. Born on May 7, 1812, in Camberwell, London, Browning grew up in a literary environment, and his love for poetry was cultivated early in life. His works, often characterized by rich language, complex themes, and psychological insight, had a significant impact on Victorian literature.

1. Early Life and Education:

   Robert Browning was the son of Robert Browning, a bank clerk, and Sarah Anna Wiedemann Browning. His father was a book collector, and Browning was exposed to a wide range of literature from a young age. He began writing poetry in his early adolescence, and by the age of twelve, he had written a book of poetry.

   Browning was largely self-taught, and he had an insatiable curiosity for literature, philosophy, and the arts. He attended the University of London for a short period but left without completing his degree. His unconventional education and voracious reading laid the foundation for the intellectual depth found in his later works.

2. Early Works:

   Browning's early poetic works, including "Pauline" (1833) and "Paracelsus" (1835), received limited attention. However, these early works showcased his ambition and experimentation with form and style. It was during this time that he developed a fascination with the dramatic monologue, a form that would become central to his later achievements.

3. Meeting Elizabeth Barrett:

   One of the most pivotal events in Browning's life was his meeting with fellow poet Elizabeth Barrett in 1845. Barrett was already an established and celebrated poet, and the two began exchanging letters and poems. Despite Barrett's poor health and the objections of her father, the couple secretly married in 1846 and moved to Italy.

   The love between Robert and Elizabeth profoundly influenced Browning's poetry. His poems dedicated to her, such as "Sonnets from the Portuguese," are revered for their intensity and emotional depth. Elizabeth's death in 1861 deeply affected Browning, and he would spend the rest of his life in Italy, seldom returning to England.

4. Dramatic Monologues:

   Browning's innovative use of the dramatic monologue distinguishes him as a poet. The dramatic monologue is a form that allows a speaker to reveal their character, thoughts, and emotions to an implied audience. Browning's mastery of this form is exemplified in works such as "My Last Duchess," "The Bishop Orders His Tomb at Saint Praxed's Church," and "Fra Lippo Lippi." These poems showcase Browning's ability to create complex characters and explore the depths of human psychology through the monologue form.

5. Notable Works:

   - "Dramatic Lyrics" (1842): This collection marked Browning's venture into the dramatic monologue. It includes "My Last Duchess" and "Porphyria's Lover," both of which exemplify Browning's exploration of the darker aspects of human nature.

   - "The Ring and the Book" (1868-1869): A lengthy narrative poem, "The Ring and the Book" is considered one of Browning's masterpieces. It tells the same story from multiple perspectives, exploring themes of truth, justice, and morality.

   - "Dramatis Personae" (1864): This collection features some of Browning's most renowned monologues, including "Rabbi Ben Ezra" and "Caliban upon Setebos."

   - "The Pied Piper of Hamelin" (1842): Although known for his dramatic monologues, Browning also wrote narrative poetry. "The Pied Piper of Hamelin" is a well-known example, showcasing his versatility.

6. Influence and Recognition:

   Browning's works were not always immediately embraced by critics, and his dense and often obscure style was not universally appreciated during his lifetime. However, he did find a dedicated readership, and his reputation grew steadily. In the latter part of the 19th century, Browning's poetry gained greater recognition, and he became a respected figure in literary circles.

   His impact extended beyond his contemporaries, influencing later writers such as T.S. Eliot, Ezra Pound, and Robert Frost. Browning's exploration of the human psyche and his use of multiple perspectives were particularly influential in the development of modernist literature.

7. Legacy and Later Life:

   Robert Browning continued to write prolifically throughout his life. In addition to poetry, he also wrote plays, essays, and critical works. His later works include "Asolando" (1889), a collection of poems published shortly before his death.

   Browning died on December 12, 1889, in Venice, Italy. Despite initial mixed critical reception, his legacy endured, and he is now regarded as one of the Victorian era's most important poets. The Browning Society, founded in 1881, continues to promote the study and appreciation of his works.

8. Conclusion:

   Robert Browning's contributions to literature, particularly his mastery of the dramatic monologue, have left an indelible mark on poetry. His exploration of complex characters, psychological depth, and innovative use of form continue to be celebrated. Browning's life and works reflect a profound engagement with the intellectual and artistic currents of his time, making him a central figure in Victorian literature and a poet whose influence extends well into the modern era.

7. Style and Structure

"My Last Duchess" by Robert Browning is a masterful example of dramatic monologue, showcasing Browning's distinctive style and a carefully crafted structure. In this exploration, we'll delve into the elements that define the poem's style, including its language, tone, use of dramatic irony, and the overall structure that enhances the narrative.

1. Dramatic Monologue:

   The poem is presented in the form of a dramatic monologue, a style for which Browning became renowned. In a dramatic monologue, a single character speaks directly to an implied audience, providing insights into their thoughts, emotions, and, often, a narrative. This form allows Browning to explore the psychology of his characters deeply. In "My Last Duchess," the Duke serves as both narrator and protagonist, unfolding the story as he showcases a portrait of his late wife to a visitor.

2. Language and Diction:

   Browning's language in "My Last Duchess" is precise, formal, and marked by a sense of aristocratic refinement. The Duke, as the speaker, employs an elevated vocabulary that befits his noble status. His language is carefully chosen to convey not only his thoughts but also his desire to present himself in a favorable light. The use of archaic terms and expressions adds a sense of historical authenticity, placing the poem in the context of the Renaissance period.

   The Duke's diction also reveals his character. He uses words like "commands" and "just commands" to emphasize his authority and control. The repetition of possessive pronouns such as "my" and "I" underscores the Duke's possessiveness and egocentric nature. The refined language and calculated choice of words contribute to the creation of a character who is simultaneously charming and unsettling.

3. Tone:

   The tone of the poem is crucial in conveying the Duke's character and attitude toward the events he describes. The Duke adopts a conversational and seemingly amiable tone, as if casually recounting the story of the portrait. However, beneath this veneer of politeness, a darker tone emerges as the Duke reveals his jealousy, possessiveness, and the circumstances surrounding the Duchess's demise. The dissonance between the tone and the underlying emotions adds to the dramatic impact of the monologue.

4. Use of Enjambment and Caesura:

   Browning's use of enjambment, where a line of poetry extends into the next without a grammatical pause, contributes to the natural flow of the Duke's narrative. This technique creates a conversational rhythm, as if the Duke is sharing his thoughts in real-time. The absence of rigid structure in the lines reflects the Duke's casual manner of storytelling.

   Additionally, Browning employs caesura, deliberate pauses within a line, to control the pacing and emphasize certain phrases. For example, in the lines "Oh sir, she smiled, no doubt, / Whene'er I passed her; but who passed without / Much the same smile?" the caesura after "Oh sir" and "without" punctuates the Duke's recounting, drawing attention to his perception of the Duchess's smiles.

5. Irony and Unreliable Narrator:

   Dramatic irony is a notable feature of "My Last Duchess." The Duke, in his attempt to portray himself as the victim of the Duchess's perceived transgressions, unwittingly reveals his own moral shortcomings. The reader, armed with the knowledge of the Duke's possessiveness and the consequences of his actions, interprets the events differently than the Duke presents them. This creates a tension between the Duke's narrative and the reader's understanding, heightening the emotional impact of the poem.

   The unreliable narrator trope is integral to Browning's exploration of the Duke's character. The Duke's skewed perspective and selective presentation of facts invite readers to question the accuracy of his account. The gaps in the narrative, particularly regarding the Duchess's fate, leave room for interpretation and contribute to the ambiguity surrounding the events.

6. Structure and Stanza Form:

   The poem consists of 56 rhymed couplets, forming a cohesive structure. The rhyme scheme is AABB, and the consistent rhythm provides stability to the narrative. This formal structure contrasts with the unsettling content of the Duke's speech, creating a tension between form and content.

   The use of rhymed couplets contributes to the poem's musicality, enhancing the Duke's seemingly affable tone. However, the rigid structure also mirrors the Duke's desire for control and order. The deliberate choice of a structured form serves as a reflection of the Duke's attempt to impose a sense of order on the chaotic emotions underlying the narrative.

7. Symbolism and Imagery:

   Browning employs symbolism and vivid imagery to enhance the thematic depth of the poem. The portrait of the Duchess becomes a powerful symbol, representing both her life and the Duke's control. The mention of the "spot of joy" on her cheek and the artist's skill in capturing her genuine smiles create a poignant image of the Duchess's vivacity. The choice to cover the portrait with a curtain becomes a symbolic act, reflecting the Duke's desire to conceal the true nature of his late wife.

   The use of the portrait as a metaphor for the Duke's control over the Duchess's image and emotions adds layers of meaning to the narrative. The careful selection of visual details, such as the "depth and passion of its earnest glance," contributes to the reader's understanding of the characters and their relationships.

8. Exploration of Themes:

   The poem's style is intricately woven into its thematic exploration. The themes of power, control, jealousy, and the objectification of women are not only conveyed through the content of the monologue but are also embedded in Browning's stylistic choices. The language, tone, and structure work in tandem to create a narrative that immerses the reader in the psychological complexities of the Duke and the disturbing nature of his relationships.

In conclusion, "My Last Duchess" exemplifies Robert Browning's distinctive style and mastery of the dramatic monologue. Through carefully chosen language, tone, structure, and the use of irony, Browning crafts a narrative that goes beyond a mere recounting of events. The poem becomes a psychological exploration, inviting readers to grapple with the complexities of human relationships, power dynamics, and the consequences of unchecked ego and possessiveness. Browning's enduring impact lies in his ability to use poetic form not just as a vessel for storytelling but as a means of delving into the depths of the human psyche.